• Article highlight
  • Article tables
  • Article images

Article History

Received : 19-04-2021

Accepted : 30-04-2021

Available online : 12-06-2021



Article Metrics




Downlaod Files

   


Article Access statistics

Viewed: 130

PDF Downloaded: 103


Ganjale and Dhamoji: Study of effectiveness of local vinegar (Acetic Acid) in infected orthopaedic wound management


Introduction

Wound infections are commonly encountered in our day to day orthopaedic practice. It can be a sequele to compound fractures or post operative surgical incisional wound infection. Pseudomonas aeruginosa was common opportunistic pathogen found commonly on culture and resistant to majority of antibiotics used routinely. It is also one of the important cause of nosocomial hospital acquired infection. Recently increased frequency of resistant strains because of its ability to survive in hospital environment and ability to develop resistance have been reported. 1 Pseudomonas is difficult nosocomial pathogen to eliminate from infection site. The resistant strains and incidence of multiple drug resistant strains are difficult to treat and eradicate. It is also resistant to many of commonly used disinfectants antiseptics.

Aims and Objectives

To study the usefulness of vinegar Acetic acid and its effectiveness in infected orthopaedic wound management.

Materials and Methods

A prospective study was conducted on 14 cases of orthopaedic infected wounds from November 2019 to December 2020 to study the effectiveness of using local vinegar acetic acid on infected wounds.

Inclusion criteria

  1. Compound wounds which were non suturable irregular in shape and size but could be approximated well, primary and secondary debrided wounds.

  2. Surgical incisional wounds which got infected in early post operative period of 8-10 days.

According to our antibiotic protocols we administered three days of parenteral antibiotics followed by oral antibiotics for five days. Incisional wounds were inspected on 2nd 5th 7th day and suture were removed on 10 to 12th day. Antibiotics used were ceftriaxone Cefotaxime and cefuroxime.

All compound lacerated wounds were primarily debrided with copious normal saline hydrogen peroxide all visible dirt and contamination grit were removed. The skin edges were debrided and sutured which were suturable. And those lacerated compound wounds which were non suturable, edges were debrided and approximated loosely to allow wound healing secondarily with traditional dressings. Cultures sensitivity of infected wounds was sent on slightest suspicion of infection. We selected those cases which were not responding to regular dressings and culture sensitivity test revealed pseudomonas infection not responding to any antibiotics or the antibiotics were costly which patients could not afford to buy costly sensitive effective antibiotic.

The sites of infected wounds considered for study were at elbow, leg thigh, gluteal region forearm. Out of 14 cases 5 were post operative incisional wound infection, at elbow (orif olecranon plating done and 1 TBW done, gluteal region Bipolar replacement surgery was done (1 case), proximal part of leg proximal tibia locking plate was fixed (2 cases). 8 cases were compound wounds over leg (2 cases), forearm, (2 cases), arm (1case), thigh(1 case) and foot (2 cases).

Actual dressing procedure: the infected wound was dressed under all aseptic precautions. A) the wound wash was given and cleansed with copious normal saline hydrogen peroxide irrigation. B) all necrotic tissue and slough and unhealthy tissue was excised C) Sterile guage soaked in 5% acetic acid was placed over wound and additional dry pads were placed and pressure bandage was applied. This dressing was continued daily or on alternate days as per condition of wound healing. Affected limb was kept in elevated position to enhance subsidence of oedema. Wound healing was recorded and documented in pictorial format for study.

Results

Incisional wounds healed well sooner at 10- 18 days, but compound wounds took longer time about 3 -4 weeks. Daily dressings were done. The compound wounds which were debrided and approximated with loose sutures were injected at edges to enhance healing. The wound was dressed inspected regularly and condition of infected wound assessed by its reduced inflammatory response subsiding oedema of skin edges epithelisation and decreasing size of wound. Some large compound wound in our study needed plastic surgery for skin and soft tissue cover. The smaller wounds healed well with granulation tissue and epithelisation of edges without any secondary procedure.

Figure 1

Case 1: A: ORIF proximal ulna plating was done. Post operative wound infection at 10th day; B and C: Debridement and secondary suturing and local infiltration of Vinegar in the wound; D: at 16th day; E: Healing wound edges; F: Completely healed operative wound over elbow

https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/typeset-prod-media-server/2ac62f01-c081-42d1-8d8e-62363a8b0751image1.png

Figure 2

Case 2: A: Compound fracture tibia fibula stabilized by external fixator and debridement of wound and loose approximation of skin edges was done which subsequently got blackish discoloration and necrosed; B: Debrided necrotic skin edges and started dressings with local vinegar soaked gauges and infiltration in skin edges; C: Dressings with vinegar soaked gauges continued; D: Subsequently healing with granulation tissue at 3 weeks and was skin grafted later

https://typeset-prod-media-server.s3.amazonaws.com/article_uploads/c6c93a7c-1883-4100-bfc6-c4e2a3f6510f/image/ec3ce77e-1789-4352-b0dd-9f24ef30b510-uimage.png

Figure 3

Case 3: A: Eschar on posterior aspect of arm; B: After debridement and starting local vinegar; C: Granulation of open wound and size of wound decreased at 18 days with local vinegar dressings

https://typeset-prod-media-server.s3.amazonaws.com/article_uploads/c6c93a7c-1883-4100-bfc6-c4e2a3f6510f/image/3b01ad6a-6a58-4b09-b67a-70ef35a15520-uimage.png

Figure 4

Case 4: A: On admission wound on left foot; B: Primary debridement and suturing; C: at 7th day; D: Healing at 18th day

https://typeset-prod-media-server.s3.amazonaws.com/article_uploads/c6c93a7c-1883-4100-bfc6-c4e2a3f6510f/image/f1967f6c-3c16-4bfe-ac53-7c72fb59cd2c-uimage.png

Discussion

Wound infection encountered in orthopaedic practice are mainly because of two reasons. 1) Compound fracture wounds with irregular skin and soft tissue damage which cannot be sutured primarily, associated contamination, diseases like diabetes, atherosclerosis with decreased vascularity and wound perfusion plus the surgical insult on soft tissue for stabilizing fractured bones with proper implants. 2) Surgical incisional wound infections in post operative period caused because damage caused primarily by trauma on soft tissue leading to contusion and swelling of surrounding fractured bones, surgical dissection, collection of haematoma in potential space and getting infected in due course of time, after improper surgical wound closure, improper unhygineinic wound care, associated skin wounds like abrasions bruise nearby surgical incision, and associated tender skin seen in elderly and diabetics.

All these factors predispose for wound infection. Staphylococcus aureus Staph Epidermidis and MRSA are majority of bacteria those contaminate compound wounds and incisional wounds.2 Pseudomonas aeruginosa is classic opportunistic infection is most commonly encountered in orthopaedic practice and burns. Its resistant strains and resistance to various antibiotics disinfectants antiseptics poses a challenge for a treating orthopaedic surgeon. Orthopaedic surgeon stabilizes the fractured bone by fixing it using different implants and prosthesis. Infection of implanted bone is very difficult to treat, as it cannot be removed till the bone unites and infection persists till there is implant in the body. One has to be very careful to prevent infection and also be ready to treat the infection caused, Compound fractures and compound wounds and surgical incisional wound infections are commonly seen in orthopaedic practice. Of course mainstay treatment of infected wound is repeated debridement wound wash and aseptic wound care along with proper parenteral / oral/ local antibiotics depending on culture sensitivity. It is found pseudomonas are commonly cultured and are resistant to routine antibiotics. At times, they are sensitive to antibiotics which are costly and are not affordable to the patients.

There are many local disinfectants antiseptic agents used for infected wound care, but it is not without its side effects like skin irritation, skin discoloration, allergies, intolerance, toxicity etc.3, 4 To name few examples, antiseptic agents like hydrogen peroxide iodine and alcohol have cytotoxic effects. Hydrogen peroxide and disrupts new capillaries oxidizes wound debris and is toxic to fibroblasts. Dakins solution containing hypochlorite is also toxic to fibroblasts and slow down the epithelisation and retards collagen synthesis inhibits migration of neutrophils migration in wound bed.5, 6, 7 Betadine Povidone iodine commonly used antiseptic agent is broad spectrum antibacterial and anti fungal agent.8, 9 It impairs wound healing and reduces wound strength and deleterious effect on epithelisation when used in undiluted concentration. Silver sulfa diazine is toxic to fibroblasts and can have allergic reaction and transient leucopenia.10

Philips et al. was first to report use of acetic acid as topical agent in pseudomonas aeroginsa infected superficial wounds.2 Dilute acetic acid in concentration of 1 to 3% is successfully used by many workers for pseudomaonal infected wounds but not without side effects. These agents are cytotoxic and can retard healing process and can do more harm if they are not judiciously used in proper concentration. There is evidence on InVitro studies on effect of acetic acid studied by various workers against pseudomonas aeruginosa isolates. Husain et al. were first to analyse sensitivity of pseudomonas aeruginosa from burn wounds and found acetic acid as effectively active against pseudomonas in concentration of 0.1 to 10% they found acetic acid at a concentration of 2% was highly effective against P aeruginosa. In Vitro susceptibility to acetic acid was also studied by Juma et al.by using different concentration 0.5 and reported highest zone of inhibition at concentration of 2%.6, 11

There are studies by various workers on use of Boric acid, citric acid and have shown better results. Kujath and Hugelschaffer 1987 used 3% boric acid. Mujumdar in 1993 used ascorbic acid in burn wounds. Citric acid was found simple reliable non toxic effective economical approach in superficial P aeruginosa infections.6, 12

Vinegar is an acidic liquid formed by oxidation of ethanol in alcohol containing liquid such as wine fermented fruit juice (cider) or beer. It has been used since ancient times as important cooking ingredient.13 The mechanism of action of acetic acid is concerned, it is suggested that acidification of a wound also increases the pO2 and reduces the histotoxicity of ammonia which may be present (ammonia being less toxic in an acidic environment). This acidification of a wound is, however, relatively short-lived and it has been found in one study that the wound does not maintain acidity for periods longer than about few hours and therefore soaks would require frequent replacement.7 In this study, we changed the acetic acid soaked gauze every six hours though some study have got excellent results with even single daily gauze replacement

Topical application or subcutaneous injection in local skin in concentration of 3-5% eliminated pseudomonas from burns and soft tissue wounds.4 Acetic acid acts against P aeruginosa by lowering the pH and thereby making an environment unsuitable for growth and multilicatin og P aeruginosa. It also confers other benefits on healing process as well as removal of bacteria. The effect on re epithelisation has found no negative impact on wound healing (Kjolseth et al. 1994)6, 14 Al-Ibran and Khan studied effect of 1% acetic acid in burn wounds with 90% success.13

Wounds are classified as either acute or chronic. Acute wounds heal in a predictable manner and time frame. Chronic wounds are defined as wounds that have failed to proceed through the orderly process that produces satisfactory anatomic and functional integrity or that have proceeded through the repair process without producing an adequate anatomic and functional result (Hopf et al., 2006). The incidence of wound infection is about 5% to 10% nationwide and has not changed during the last few decades (Arnold and Barbul, 2008).15, 1, 16 Pseudomonal infection in hospitalized patients has always been problem to the clinicians. Traditional therapies with antipseudomonal agents have their own limitations because of multiple antibiotic resistance in nosocomial strains of P. aeruginosa. The use of acetic acid has been reported from time to time as a topical agent for the treatment of pseudomonal infections and in most reports has been used for superficial infection (Nagoba et al., 1997).10 Dressings can be classified as primary or secondary. A primary dressing is placed directly on the wound and may provide absorption of fluids and prevent desiccation, infection, and adhesion of a secondary dressing. A secondary dressing is one that is placed on the primary dressing for further protection, absorption, compression, and occlusion. Many types of dressings exist and are designed to achieve certain clinically desired endpoints (Martinez-Zapata et al., 2012).17

Factors promoting infected wound healing

Debulk slough necrotic tissue by non traumatic debridement repeatedly. Use of non irritable non allergic safe economical and effective local antiseptic. Keep wound bed healthy. Control of pain, Elevation to enhance subsidence of swelling of affected limb.

Conclusion

A wound is said to be infected when the invading micro organisms cause notably impaired wound healing. When infectious bacteris are invading a host toxic substances are produced by microorganisms that cause damage to the host tissues. (Gjodsbol.et al. 2006) 1, 18, 11, 4

Administration of local vinegar in wound edges or locally vinegar soaked gauges over the wound in conjunction with parenteral antibiotics is attractive to orthopaedic surgeons seeking to reduce the incidence of skin and soft tissue infection. Vivek Patel and Vishal Pushkarna have shown the effectiveness of intra wound vancomycin to prevent surgical site infections. 2

Acetic acid was found to have bacteriostatic activity against Pseudomonas Aeruginosa. It is used in concentration of 1 to 5% to eradicate efficiently eradicate the Pseudomona Aeruginosa from infection site in superficial wounds. Acetic acid have advantage over costly antibiotics and local antiseptics and does not encourage evolution of multiple drug resistant strains in hospital environment. At times when bacterial resistance to antibiotics is a matter of concern, the value of topical agents such as acetic acid can be efficiently and effectively used in pseudomonal infected wound. Use of antiseptics at a concentration that is effective and well tolerated and discontinued as soon as clinical signs of infection disappear can be practiced safely.

Infection leads to complications which are incomparable in terms of financial burden quality of life functional outcome of any orthopaedic surgery.

This was an initial attempt to study in Government hospital with majority population of low socioeconomic status smoking alcoholism tobacco chewing males not affording costly higher antibiotics. The studies showed good encouraging and promising results and were cost effective. Multiple and more trials are required to assess good results.

Source of Funding

Nil.

Conflicts of Interest

Nil.

References

1 

BS Nagoba SP Selkar BJ Wadher RC Gandhi Acetic acid treatment of pseudomonal wound infections--a reviewJ Infect Public Health201364105

2 

VA Patel VA Pushkarna How effective is intrawound vancomycin with multidiscipline approach for preventing surgical site infections (SSI) in arthroplasty and orthopedic surgeries: a study in non Covid 19 to Covid 19 eraIndian J Orthop Surg2020643031010.18231/j.ijos.2020.056

3 

TK Hunt HW Hopf Wound healing and wound infection - what surgeons and anaesthesiologists can do?Surg Clin N Am199777587606

4 

JM Sloss N Cumberland SM Milner Acetic acid used for the elimination of Pseudomonas aeruginosa from burn and soft tissue woundsJ R Army Med Corps19931392495110.1136/jramc-139-02-04

5 

HD Dakins The antiseptic action of hypochlorites: the ancient history of the new antisepticBr Med J1915280910

6 

D Kjolseth JM Frank JH Barkar GL Anderson AI Rosenthal RD Acland Comparison of the effects of commonly used wound agents on epithelization and neovascularizationJ Am Coll Surg199417930512

7 

SA Kramer Effect of povidone-iodine on wound healing: a reviewJ Vasc Nurs1999171723

8 

MN Khan AH Naqui Antiseptics, iodine, povidone iodine and traumatic wound cleansingJ Tissue Viability200616461010.1016/s0965-206x(06)64002-3

9 

RA Kozol Effects of Sodium Hypochlorite (Dakin's Solution) on Cells of the Wound ModuleArch Surg19881234420310.1001/archsurg.1988.01400280026004

10 

BS Nagoba SP Selkar BJ Wadher RC Gandhi Acetic acid treatment of pseudomonal wound infections – A reviewJ Infect Public Health201366410510.1016/j.jiph.2013.05.005

11 

I Phillips AZ Lobo R Fernandes NS Gundara Acetic acid in the treatment of superficial wounds infected by Pseudomonas aeruginosaLancet1968291753211310.1016/s0140-6736(68)90004-4

12 

P Kujath C Hugeschaffer Pseudomonas aeruginosa: pathogenicity, prevention, and therapeutic approachesZentralblatt fur Chirurgie198711255863

13 

E Al-Ibran M Khan Efficacy of topical application of 1% acetic acid in eradicating pseudomonal infections in burn woundsJ Dow Univ Health Sci20104903

14 

IM Juma HS Yass FH Al-Jaber A comparison between the effect of acetic acid and salicyclic acid in different concentrations on Pseudomonas aeruginosa isolated from burn wound infectionsJ Tech2007201738

15 

MA Arnold A Barbul JL Cameron Surgical site infectionsCurrent Surgical Therapy9th editionMosby ElsevierSt. Louis2008115260

16 

A Barbul DT Efron Sl Kavalukas FC Brunicardi AT Billiar Wound Healing Schwartz’s Principles of Surgery 9th edition2010378432

17 

MJ Martinez-Zapata AJ Marti-Carvajal I Sola Autologous platelet-rich plasma for treating chronic woundsCochrane Database Syst Rev201210CD006899

18 

K Gjødsbøl JJ Christensen T Karlsmark B Jørgensen BM Klein KA Krogfelt Multiple bacterial species reside in chronic wounds: a longitudinal studyInt Wound J2006332253110.1111/j.1742-481x.2006.00159.x



jats-html.xsl

© This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.




Wiki in hindi