• Article highlight
  • Article tables
  • Article images

Article History

Received : 13-05-2024

Accepted : 04-06-2024



Article Metrics




Downlaod Files

   


Article Access statistics

Viewed: 171

PDF Downloaded: 89


Get Permission Sharma, Thoudam, Garg, Das, Kevadiya, and Gupta: A study of functional outcome of bimalleolar fracture with syndesmotic injury after open reduction and internal fixation in young adults


Introduction

The malleolar fractures in the ankle is one of the commonest fractures in day to day orthopaedic practices. Like the other intra articular fractures, malleolar fracture requires appropriate reduction and a proper stable fixation. When the malleolar fractures are not accurately reduced, they can lead to post injury painful movement restrictions of the ankle, osteoarthritis, or both.1

Approximately around 3 centuries ago, scientific studies had begun with Sir Percival Pott, who in his paper in the year 1768 stated some of the remarks on dislocations and fractures that had discussed the fracture complex happening at the ankle joint. Dupuytren, Tillaux Chaput, Maisonneuve, Leforte-wagstaffe and others analysed ankle joint injuries.

After examining numerous cases thoroughly in the year 1922, Ashhurt and Bromer categorized and assessed injuries around the ankle by taking into account the forces direction acting upon them. In the years 1948-1954, Lauge-Hansen identified four distinct categories by analyzing pure injury sequences and considered factors such as the timing of injury, the deforming force direction, and the position of the foot.2

Ankle injuries are significant because they involve the transmission of body weight through joints, which is crucial for mobility. These injuries are typically a combination of ligamentous and bony damage, and each injury results from a sequence of failures due to deforming forces. Malleolar fractures, in particular, have different presentations that have led to the development of various classification systems. Two such systems that are commonly used are the Lauge Hansen and Danis-Weber classification systems.1

The ankle joint are highly susceptible to injuries. This is due to its relatively mobile nature and it bears much of the stresses associated while weight bearing. The ankle joint supports more weight per unit area in comparison with any other joint in our body. The ankle joint can bear upto five times our body weight.3 Sir Robert Jones mention that the ankle joint is the most injured joint of our body but it is the least well treated. Ankle injuries are very significant because body weight transmission occurs through them, and the locomotion depends upon the joint stability. Many of the ankle joint injuries are both ligamentous components and bony components. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is a useful diagnostic tool to determine ligamentus injury. During the year 1948-1954, four patterns based on pure injury sequences were recognized by Lauge-Hansen and were taken into account at the time of ankle injury, it showed deforming force direction and position of the foot. To prevent complications, like other intra articular fractures, it is crucial to achieve anatomical reduction by using the open reduction and internal fixation for bimalleolar ankle fracture. The results of bimalleolar ankle injuries are improved with emphasis given on the anatomical reduction of the fracture and stable fixation and regaining full fibular length, and early active painless mobilization since the advent of AO principles of management.

As for the management of malleolar fractures, the stable fractures are treated by conservative management and have provided great results. Whereas the unstable fractures , displaced and the open fractures requires open reduction internal fixation of the fracture. The superiority of the ORIF over conservative management have been thoroughly demonstrated in the literature. The operative method restores the joint anatomy and contact-loading characteristic of the ankle. The add on advantages are earlier rehabilitation and recovery without cast, and earlier weight bearing.1

Materials and Methods

This was a prospective study, which included 20 cases of closed bimalleolar fractures, who were treated surgically at Maharishi Markandeshwar Institute of Medical Sciences and Research, Mullana, Ambala from June 2022 to June 2024.

Inclusion criteria

  1. Patient with displaced unstable bimalleolar fracture.

  2. Closed bimalleolar fracture.

  3. Bimalleolar fracture with syndesmotic injury.

  4. Patient above 18 years and below 30 years.

Exclusion criteria

  1. Patient below 18 years, and above 30 years of age.

  2. Patient with medical contraindications to the surgery.

  3. Paralytic limb.

  4. Others associated fractures in the ipsilateral limb.

  5. Patients who have not give consent for the study.

All patients were all evaluated pre-operatively in context to general information like name, sex, age, occupation and address. A detailed history to find out the mode and mechanism of injury was taken. Clinical examination was done in detail to rule out other associated injuries. Anteroposterior, mortise and lateral radiograph of the ankle joints were obtained with other relevant x-rays if needed. Initially patients was supplemented with analgesics and the affected lower limb splinted with below knee slab. Consent was taken from the patient.. All patients of ankle fractures underwent surgery as soon as patients were fit . A dose of intravenous cefuroxime injection (antibiotic) was given after checking the sensitivity on the previous night of surgery and on OT table before beginning the surgery. Antibiotic coverage was continued in post-operative period.

Post-operatively Intravenous cefuroxime antibiotic coverage with adequate analgesia were given. The intravenous antibiotic was administered for 5 days followed up oral antibiotics till suture removal.

Xrays of the Ankle- AP, Lateral and Mortise view was taken on 1st post-operative day. First wound examination on post op day 2 and then on post op day 5 and surgical wound dressings were done. Intermittent Ankle movements was started within 3 to 4 days. Sutures removal were done on the 14th post operative day after assessing the wound status. Use of the slab was discontinued after 3 weeks after looking at the wound status, initial partial- weight bearing was allowed after 4-6 weeks but full weight bearing was started on 10 to 12 weeks which will depend on clinical examination and x-ray.

Assessment of results

The radiological and functional results were given analysis using the ankle scoring system of Baird and Jackson. The evaluation was based on a questionnaire, physical and radiological examinations. The physical examinations were measurements of active dorsi-flexion and plantar -flexion of the injured ankle in comparison with the uninjured ankle, with forepart of foot in neutral position. Radiologically, the medial clear space, the superior joint space and talar tilt were measured.

Table 1

The Baird and Jackson scoring system are given below:

Parameters

Score

1. Pain

No pain.

15

Mild pain while patient performed strenuous activity

12

Mild pain while patient performed daily living.

8

Pain while patient performed weight bearing

4

Pain at rest

0

2. Stability of ankle

No clinical noticed instability

15

Instability while patient performed sports activities

5

Instability while patient performed activites of daily living ability to walk

0

3. Ability to walk

Patient’s ability to walk the desired distances without limp or pain.

15

Patient’s ability to walk the desired distances with some mild limp or pain.

12

Moderate restriction while walking.

8

Patient’s ability to walk short distance only.

4

Pateint is inable to walk

0

4. Ability to run

Patient’s Ability to run the desired distance without pain.

10

Patient’s ability to run desired distances with some slight pain.

8

Moderate restriction on running with mild pain

6

Patient’s ability to run short distance only.

3

Patient’s inability to run

0

5. Ability to work

Patient’s ability to perform the usual occupation without restriction.

10

Patient’s ability to perform the usual occupation with restrictions in strenuous activities

8

Patient’s ability to perform the usual occupation with little substantial restrictions.

6

Partially disabled, can do only selected jobs.

3

Patient’s inability to work

0

6. Motion of the ankle

Less than 10% of the uninjured ankle.

10

Less than 15% of the uninjured ankle.

7

Less than 20% of the uninjured ankle

4

Less than <50% of the uninjured ankle, or dorsiflexion <5

0

7. Radiographic result

Intact mortise which is normal medial clear space, normal- 2mm superior joint space and no talar tilt seen.

25

Same like the above with some mild reactive changes at the joint margins .

15

Narrowed superior joint space, superior joint space of 2mm and talar tilt more than >2mm

10

Moderate narrowing of superior joint space, with superior space of between 2 and 1mm.

5

Severe narrowed superior joint space with superior joint space

0

[i] Baird and Jackson scoring sytem:

[ii] Excellent results: 96 -100

[iii] Good results: 91 - 95

[iv] Fair results: 81 - 90

[v] Poor results: 0 – 80

[vi] Maximum possible score - 100

Illustration case (Figure 1, Figure 2, Figure 3, Figure 4, Figure 5)

  1. Age: 30

  2. Sex: Male

  3. Injury surgery interval: 2 days

  4. Classification: Lauge-Hansen- SER

  5. Complications: Nil

Figure 1

Pre-op x-ray

https://typeset-prod-media-server.s3.amazonaws.com/article_uploads/7c0ae6c9-4d97-4447-a8c6-2ff038b9fa7c/image/69cb2eb4-4eb7-40ef-b850-0d8ee8546b5f-uimage.png

Figure 2

Approach to the lateral malleolus

https://typeset-prod-media-server.s3.amazonaws.com/article_uploads/7c0ae6c9-4d97-4447-a8c6-2ff038b9fa7c/image/41e4257f-8db9-4c92-8845-cbba7ea8716b-uimage.png

Figure 3

Approach to the medial malleolus

https://typeset-prod-media-server.s3.amazonaws.com/article_uploads/7c0ae6c9-4d97-4447-a8c6-2ff038b9fa7c/image/e76f3e0d-77fe-4232-9f95-11c36a65c056-uimage.png

Figure 4

Immediate post op x-ray

https://typeset-prod-media-server.s3.amazonaws.com/article_uploads/7c0ae6c9-4d97-4447-a8c6-2ff038b9fa7c/image/659b6f06-ad47-4e72-84bc-e86b02d9259f-uimage.png

Figure 5

Range of motion after 6 months of follow up

https://typeset-prod-media-server.s3.amazonaws.com/article_uploads/7c0ae6c9-4d97-4447-a8c6-2ff038b9fa7c/image/5ce2c562-f5d5-4aeb-887f-395aea474ed1-uimage.png

Observation and Results

It was a prospective study including 20 patients who had bimalleolar fracture. They were all treated surgically at MMIMSR, Mullana, Ambala from June 2022 to June 2024.

The maximum occurence of the injury occured in the third decade of life, with injury which were more common in males- 15 cases (75%) than females- 5 cases (25%). The side more commonly involved was left- 11 cases (55%) as compared to right- 9 cases (45%). Road traffic accidents accounted to majority of the injuries (65%) with second being self fall and twisting accounting to 35%. Out of the 20 patients, 8 are PER pattern, 7 are SER pattern, 3 are PA pattern and SA pattern accounting to 3 patients. Commonest injury pattern observed in my study was Pronation- External rotation type, followed by Supination External Rotation type. According to Baird and Jackson scoring system , out of 20 cases 65% had good to excelent result, 55% had fair result and 10% had poor functional outcome. In our study, mean for radiological union in 6 months period was 13.45 weeks.

Table 2

The various results are displayed

Sex ratio

Sex ratio

No. of patients

Male

15

Female

5

Side involved

Side involved

Number of patients

Left

11

Right

9

Mode of injury

Mode of injury

Number of patients

Self fall, twisting.

7

Road traffic accidents.

13

On the basis of positioning of foot while injury and the direction of the force applied to the foot, four types of injury patterns which was described by Lauge-Hansen and their incidences.(Figure 6) The results are the following:

Graph 1

Injury pattern

https://typeset-prod-media-server.s3.amazonaws.com/article_uploads/7c0ae6c9-4d97-4447-a8c6-2ff038b9fa7c/image/829b66ae-e34b-49a5-ac0b-781dec93b20b-uimage.png

Based on the fibula fracture level, the AO classification expands on Danis-Weber, the following distributions were seen.(Figure 7)

Graph 2

Danis- Weber classification

https://typeset-prod-media-server.s3.amazonaws.com/article_uploads/7c0ae6c9-4d97-4447-a8c6-2ff038b9fa7c/image/0758e4da-ed79-48c9-94dd-b0c207f031ed-uimage.png

According to Baird and Jackson, following functional outcomes were observed.

Table 3

Results

No. of patients

Percentage

Excellent

2

10%

Fair

5

25%

Good

11

55%

Poor

2

10%

Table 4

Based on the fracture pattern, the following functional outcome were observed

Subjective scoring

Fracture pattern

SER

PER

SA

PA

Excellent

2

0

0

0

Good

2

6

0

3

Fair

2

2

1

0

Poor

1

0

1

0

Table 5

Functional outcome according to sex distribution

Sex

Excellent

Good

Fair

Poor

Male

1

8

4

2

Female

1

3

1

0

Complications

The following postoperative complications were observed

  1. Superficial infections with or without skin necrosis: 2

  2. Ankle stiffness: 3

Graph 3

Management of complications

https://typeset-prod-media-server.s3.amazonaws.com/article_uploads/7c0ae6c9-4d97-4447-a8c6-2ff038b9fa7c/image/1559cca4-4e87-4168-836e-96888d49dbe2-uimage.png

Patients who encountered superficial infections, were all treated with repeated saline aseptic dressings and appropriate antibiotics. They responded well to this mode of treatment.

Discussion

Our study consist of 20 cases of closed bimalleolar ankle fractures. Injury were more common in males - 15 cases (75%) than females- 5 cases (25%). The side more commonly involved was left- 11 cases (55%) as compared to right- 9 cases (45%).

Road traffic accidents (RTA) accounted to to majority of the injuries (65%) followed by self fall and twisting injury accounting to 35% of total injury. Out of the 20 patients, 8 are PER pattern, 7 are SER pattern, 3 are PA pattern and SA pattern accounting to 3 patients.

Most common pattern of injury seen in my study was Pronation and External Rotation type. Stress radiograph is useful to assess the ankle stability.

In PER pattern, 6 out of 8 had good functional outcome, with no poor functional outcome, although 1 patient had developed complication of ankle stiffness which were managed with malleolar screws for medial malleolus fracture and plate for lateral malleolus fracture. In pronation and external rotation injury restoration of the fibular length and rotation, ankle mortise and syndesmotic stability is important factor as noted by maverick et al.4

Displacement is the talus position in a mortise of the ankle joint and it depends on the intact deep deltoid ligaments.5 Fixing of the malleolar fragments will not likely restore the ankle stability and will need to repair the deep deltoid if torn.6 Stable fractures does not displace with axial pressure.7 Treatment management are based on the fracture stability. Prognosis will be determined by the injury energy.8 Even though the Lauge and Hansen classification does describe in detail regarding the pattern of ankle injuries, however it do not deal much with syndesmotic injury pattern.

In S-ER pattern, 4 out of total 7 patients were observed to have good to excellent result, with 2 cases having complications of superficial infections, out of which a single case was treated with medial malleolus screw fixation and fixation with plate for the lateral malleolus and the second case was treated with kwire fixation of medial malleolus and plate fixation of lateral malleolus. SER4 fracture pattern are unstable kind of fractures and needs ligament reconstruction.9

As compared to other fracture pattern, Supination-Adduction pattern had fair to poor prognosis. One out of the two patients developed ankle stiffness.

The three patients with pronation and abduction injury, we fixed medial malleolus first then followed by extra periosteal plate for fibula.

Bimalleolar fractures had a good male dominance with 75% and male to female ratio of 15:5 which we compared with the study done by Motwani G N10 and Maruthi C V.11 (Table 6)

Table 6

Sex distribution seen in various studies

Study

Number of patients

Male to Female ratio

Percentage of males

Motwani GN10

40

5:1

82.5

Maruthi CV11

40

28:12

70

Present study

20

15:5

75

The commonest injury pattern was RTA - 13 patients (65%) which were compared with the study by Raj K12 and Lee et al.13 and Mohapatra A.12 (Table 7)

Table 7

Mode of injury in various studies are shown below

Study

Number of patients

Common mode of Injury

Lee et al13

168(98)

RTA

Mohapatra A, Raj K12

84(43)

RTA

Present study

20(13)

RTA

From the 20 patients, 8(40%) are PER pattern, 7 (35%) are SER pattern, 3 patients (15%) are PA pattern and 2 patients (10%) are SA pattern. Parvataneni Prathap D A,14 Roberts RS.15

Beris et al16 all had SER as the commonest pattern, whereas in our study, PER pattern was the commonest injury.(Table 8)

Table 8

Common type of injury seen in various studies

Study

Total Number of patients

Most common type of injury

Percentage

Parvataneni Prathap14

(30)

SER

(46.6)

Roberts RS15

(25)

SER

(34)

Beris et al16

(144)

SER

(45)

Our study

(20)

PER

(40)

Average time which was required for union seen radiologically was (13.45) weeks which were in compared with study by Parvataneni Prathap D A14 and Maruthi C V11 (Table 9)

Table 9

Radiological union in various studies

Study

Follow up period.

Mean for radiological union

Parvataneni Prathap D A14

6 months

(10.6) weeks

Maruthi CV11

6 months

(8) weeks

Our study

6 months

(13.45) weeks

Baird and Jackson scores - at the end of 6 months, out of the 20 patients, 2 patients (10%) had excellent score, 11 patients (55%) had good score, 5 patients(25%) had fair score and 2 patients(10%) had poor functional outcome. Similar results were also seen in other study like Shah Z A, Arif U,17 De souza et al.,18 Beris et al.,16 Motwani GN.10 The comparative results is shown below (Table 10).

Table 10

Comparative results in various studies are shown below

Study

Good to Excellent

Fair

Poor

Shah ZA, Arif U17

82.5%

12.5%

5%

Beris et al 16

74.3%

14.6%

11.1%

De souza et al18

90%

6%

4%

Motwani GN10

82.5%

12.5%

5%

Present study

65%

25%

10%

In our research, the factors of gender, age of patients, and mechanism of injury (classified according to Lauge-Hansen) did not prove to be statistically significant in determining functional outcomes. Within our sample of 20 patients, only 2 cases (10%) experienced complications such as superficial wound infections, as opposed to a study by Shah ZA and Arif U (17), in which 4 out of 20 patients developed superficial infections.

Conclusion

The goal of surgery is to obtain anatomical reduction, ankle mortise congruence, fibular length restoration, and maintain integrity of the syndesmosis. Soft tissue dissection should be kept minimal as possible to avoid further compromise in an already swollen ankle so as to avoid vascular compromise. Achieving accurate anatomical reduction, restoring articular congruity, and timely surgical fixation using appropriate implants can lead to favourable functional outcomes. It was observed that the Pronation-External Rotation pattern of injury was the most prevalent pattern in our study. We observed that plating of fibula is a better method of fixation in B2, B3, and C2 fractures of AO pattern. If a ligament injury is properly treated and fixed with anatomical soundness, functional outcomes are improved.

Sources of Funding

None.

Conflict of Interest

None.

Acknowledgments

It gives me veritable contentment in submitting my thesis, which has been a complete learning experience. By the grace of almighty, it was carried out with ease and enthusiasm for which I shall always be indebted to him.

I am grateful to Dr. B.K. AGRAWAL, M.D., dean for granting me permission and opportunity to undergo my study and collection of data at Maharishi Markandeshwar medical college and Hospital.

Foremost, I would like to express my deepest gratitude and indebtedness to my guide and guru Dr. Yogesh Sharma, Professor and HOD, Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, M M Institute of Medical Sciences and Research, Mullana, Ambala, Haryana for his valuable guidance, continuous supervision and help at every stage of this study.

My heartfelt gratitude to my parents Mr. Devkumar Thoudam and Mrs. RK Sanatombi Devi and all members of my family for their unconditional love, support, and outstanding encouragement throughout my life, who are my pillars and foundation. I am forever grateful to them, without whom this would have not been possible.

A very special thanks to close and dear friend Dr. Shalini Yurembam for continuous support and guidance throughout my journey.

I extend my sincere thanks to my close friends and colleagues Dr. Rahul Garg, Dr. Bhanuprakash and Dr. Shivang Kala for their unflinching support and motivation throughout the course of study. I also thank my juniors Dr. Samay, Dr. Shristi, Dr. Nikhil, Dr. Abhishek and Dr. Abhijeet for their support and help during the preparation of my thesis.

My sincere thanks to the MMIMSR staff, Mrs. Meeru (Stenographer) along with all non-teaching staff and all nursing staff and helper of orthopaedic ward for their prompt help whenever and wherever required.

Last but not the least this acknowledgement is incomplete if I fail in my duty to thank all subjects who whole heartedly participated in this study.

References

1 

S Kale P Tank R Ghodke P Singh A Patel Functional outcome of bimalleolar ankle fractures treated with fibular plate for lateral malleolus and C.C. screws for medial malleolusInt J Orthop Sci202061112632

2 

N Lauge-Hansen Fractures of the ankle. II. Combined experimental-surgical and experimental-roentgenologic investigationsArch Surg (1920)195060595785

3 

WH Simon S Friedenberg S Richardson Joint Congruence: A CORRELATION OF JOINT CONGRUENCE AND THICKNESS OF ARTICULAR CARTILAGE IN DOGSJ Bone Joint Surg Am1973558161420

4 

IG Yablon D Segal RE Leach JW Roach Ankle injuriesJ Pediatr Orthop198334531

5 

IG Yablon FG Heller L Shouse The key role of the lateral malleolus in displaced fractures of the ankleJ Bone Joint Surg Am197759216973

6 

ST Canale JH Beaty Campbell's Operative Orthopaedics E-Book: Expert Consult Premium Edition - Enhanced Online Features12th edElsevier Health Sciences2012

7 

KP Paudel Early weight bearing compared with non-weight bearing functional mobilization after operative treatment of an ankle fractureJ Coll Med Sci Nepal201271406

8 

PL Ramsey W Hamilton Changes in tibiotalar area of contact caused by lateral talar shiftJ Bone Joint Surg Am19765833567

9 

BG Weber LA Simpson Corrective lengthening osteotomy of the fibulaClin Orthop Relat Res1976199617

10 

GN Motwani HD Shah VH Chavli RN Daveshwar H Parmar PP Suthar Results of open reduction and internal fixation in closed bimalleolar Pott’s Fracture of Ankle in AdultsInt J Med Sci Public Health201547893900

11 

CV Maruthi N Venugopal HC Nanjundappa MK Siddalingaswamy Bimalleolar fracture of ankle joint managed by tension band wiring technique: A prospective studySch J App Med Sci201421D42832

12 

A Mohapatra K Raj Functional outcome after surgical treatment of ankle fracture using Baird Jackson scoreInt J Res Orthop201844638

13 

YS Lee CC Huang CN Chen CC Lin Operative treatment of displaced lateral malleolar fractures: the Knowles pin techniqueJ Orthop Trauma20051931927

14 

DAP Prathap A Kondlapudi S Hariprasad Functional outcome in surgical management of Bimalleolar fractures in adultsInt J Orthop201624726

15 

RS Roberts Surgical treatment of displaced ankle fracturesClin Orthop Relat Res197617216470

16 

AE Beris KT Kabbani TA Xenakis G Mitsionis PK Soucacos PN Soucacos Surgical Treatment of Malleolar Fractures; A Review of 144 PatientsClin Orthop Relat Res1976341908

17 

ZA Shah U Arif Surgical management of bimalleolar fractures of anklePak J Med Health Sci2013724713

18 

LJd Souza RB Gustilo TJ Meyer Results of operative treatment of displaced external rotation-abduction fractures of the ankleJ Bone Joint Surg Am1985677106674



jats-html.xsl


This is an Open Access (OA) journal, and articles are distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 License, which allows others to remix, tweak, and build upon the work non-commercially, as long as appropriate credit is given and the new creations are licensed under the identical terms.